This deserves to be an eloquent post, but unfortunately it turned into a ramble. Never mind, right now it’s the best I can do…
There are lots of us in The Mothers Whose Children Have Died Club. But not enough of us talk about it and new members can feel very alone. Even not so new members can feel alone. One of the bloggers I read regularly recently wrote about the death of her daughter and the temptation there is for some to say “It’s been years. Get over it.”
Do we ever get over the death of a child? What does getting over it mean anyway?
If it means forgetting – no.
If it means getting on with living – yes.
If it means going back to the way things were – no.
If it means pretending it didn’t happen – only if you are complete fool.
Our son died at home, sitting on our sofa eating dinner and wheedling at his sister to change channels on the TV. One second we were about to have dinner and the next, well, what happened? What happens in that moment is that everything changes. Every Thing. Nothing is ever like it was. Nothing is untouched. Your whole world has a new colour layered over it that you can’t remove, like a filter on a camera lens. Every thing looks different and, after a while, you are not too sure what the world used to look like.
It’s not just death that does this to us. There are a myriad of traumatic events that people all over the world experience every day. And it isn’t even just Bad Stuff that does this to us. Falling in love does it, too, and giving birth to a child, and so does climbing a mountain.
I suppose I should be drawing some profound conclusion. I’m not sure I can. It just is what it is. It’s just life and living and being human. Life isn’t static, it moves and flows. People come into our lives and people leave our lives. No experience leaves us as it found us. Some experiences are worthy of remembrance, worthy of celebration. They’ve lead us to this place and are part of who we are. What’s to get over?
The part you DO need to get over is the sting of pain that appropriates moments it should just bugger off out of, stealing into the joyous moments of your life where it has no right to be. As you delight in someone else’s new baby, it sends you a glimpse of a little ear that you remember kissing and then sneaks up on you and wallops you hard across the back of the head.
There’s a pain in every new thing you do that doesn’t include your child. Going new places where they are not known hurts. Every new friend who never knew them is a reminder that your child is no longer physically present. You carry them with you, invisibly, and it feels as if the rest of the world is ignoring your precious child, not even acknowledging that they exist. But the truth is that only you know they are there.
That’s what you do need to get beyond, because that’s the part that can become immobilising and crushing. That’s the part that starts to inflict pain on everyone around you.
I have mostly gone past that place, but I’m not sure how. I can’t explain how to do it to other grieving mothers. I wouldn’t even presume to try. But I’m grateful.









49 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 13, 2007 at 11:15 pm
myartfullife
What a beautiful job you’ve done here. I have had three friends who’ve each lost a child. What you say here gives me a better understanding. Getting past the immobilizing grief … I’m sure your post is going to help someone.
November 14, 2007 at 12:04 am
Shula
Just wanted to log in and tell you that I read it. Apart from that I have absolutely no idea what to say.
Except that you have just given me a little perspective.
x
November 14, 2007 at 12:31 am
kirsten
thank you for sharing this, kirsty.
i love reading about your son - he sounds hilarious.
November 14, 2007 at 1:27 am
Melinda
Thank you for sharing this. Your son does sound delightful.
My mother joined this club with its involuntary membership two years ago. She has moved beyond the immobilizing stage of overwhelming grief. But it (grief) will always be a part of her life. Always.
Life is forever different. I think we all have a vision of what our life will be as it unfolds in the future. And when someone you love dies unexpectedly, it’s like you’re dumped into a parallel life where everything seems the same, but is so very different.
November 14, 2007 at 1:53 am
nicolette
Such a wonderful post Kirsty. I know you never ‘get over it’. My mother lost two of her children, we have friends who lost children. We try to celebrate all their lives and to involve them in our lives, celebrations, sorrows, whenever we feel it’s appropriate. When you are able to remind those hilarious moments, that might help to heal. You certainly helped someone by telling about your wonderful son!
November 14, 2007 at 1:55 am
nicolette
Such a wonderful post Kirsty. I know you never ‘get over it’. My mother lost two of her children, we have friends who lost children. We try to celebrate all their lives and to involve them in our lives, celebrations, sorrows, whenever we feel it’s appropriate. When you are able to remind those hilarious moments, that might help to heal. You certainly helped someone by telling about your wonderful son!
November 14, 2007 at 2:29 am
Diane
Oh, Kirsty, what a lovely post and I’m so sorry that you’ve lost your son. You’ve explained the life-long grief so well. Sharing your feelings and experience is a brave and wonderful thing to do.
November 14, 2007 at 3:25 am
Velcro
What a heartbreaking post. I’m sorry I can’t write a comment worthy of it, the words just wouldn’t do it justice.
November 14, 2007 at 5:20 am
Megan
I’d call that very eloquent indeed, my friend. Words from the heart always are.
November 14, 2007 at 6:12 am
Thimbleanna
Oh Kristy, I’m so sorry for your loss. I’ve gone and read about James — what a lovely boy he must have been. It’s so hard for us who aren’t members of the club — we never know what to say because we never know what stage of grieving those of you who are in the club are at. And also because it used to be that you never talked about those things, but now, thankfully, it’s acceptable to talk about the person and celebrate their life. And remember the joy in knowing them. Thanks for a beautiful post!
November 14, 2007 at 6:32 am
Kajsa
I wish I had a coke to drink in honour of James. He sounds like a great guy. My daughter lost a baby cousin four years ago (her dad a nephew). So my kids have TWO cousins, not one as some people might think.
November 14, 2007 at 7:36 am
peppermintpatcher
Just as James’ death is a part of your experience, so too his life is part of your personality. He gave gifts of empathy and understanding to you and your children.
November 14, 2007 at 9:17 am
Violet & Rose
Kirsty, I know that this probably wasn’t your intention in writing this, but I have shed a tear for you this morning. I don’t know what else to say. Other than this WAS eloquent and beautiful and if it has helped you in some way, I’m glad. A totally selfish thing for me to say, but I hope and pray every day that I never experience a loss like yours. I’m sorry.
November 14, 2007 at 10:26 am
Maddy
Wow, I’m speechless, you are so eloquent. Beautifully written about a subject so dark that most of us dare not look in there.
When my son was diagnosed with Autism I found life was a different colour too, that day is a marker in my life when everything changed. Similar to the “before kids” feeling that parents have, I often refer to life moments as “before the diagnosis”.
Thank you for this beautifully written post and this glimpse through your window.
November 14, 2007 at 10:35 am
Stomper Girl
Well I thought you were eloquent about this Kirsty. Reading it has made me too teary to leave an articulate comment. Cx
November 14, 2007 at 11:19 am
chronicler
Very nice perspective Kirsty. I like the way you bound it up into all the experiences of life. I’ve not lost a child, my mother lost two and I a more than dear brother and a nephew. It paints your world in ways one will never know. I appreciate your willingness to share your path with us and help us gain an understanding of the loss.
November 14, 2007 at 11:33 am
rondabeyer
Thank you for sharing your wonderful son with us and the great mom he made of you. We are entering the 2nd year of my brothers suicide and it comes in waves, sometimes it seems like a tsunami, we never get over it, we move on with life, we laugh, we cry, we question, we cherish our time and we wonder why, but we do go on. Hugs to you, he is what made you the person and Mom you are and for this he will always be with us all… Thanks to you and your son, no life will never be the same, but we are lucky to have been blessed with such wonderful loved ones…..
November 14, 2007 at 1:46 pm
amandajean
thanks for sharing this post.
I haven’t lost a child, but I have lost a mother, and I think that a lot of the things parallel.
November 14, 2007 at 2:37 pm
Shirley
Unfortunately, I HAVE had someone tell me I should have “got over it by now” - but she has never had children. My Roxy will always be 4 years old to me, but on the special days, I wonder what she’d be like if she grew up. I would probably be a nana by now, as she’d be 28. I have her photos by my bed, and feel she’s always near to me.
November 14, 2007 at 4:01 pm
Patricia
Kirsty I somehow don’t think you ever get over losing someone especially your child. The pain may diminish however they are still part of you and your life. You may have known it was going to happen however the pain is the same.
November 14, 2007 at 4:15 pm
michelle
Here are some wise words from a girl who lost a brother:
http://gwendomama.blogspot.com/2007/11/i-love-that-girl.html
Thanks.
November 14, 2007 at 4:27 pm
Meggie
This is a very kind post. It is loving.
Hugs
November 14, 2007 at 9:47 pm
crafty
Very eloquent Kirsty.
November 15, 2007 at 2:03 am
Tanya Brown
Criminy, I’m so very sorry. I can’t imagine anything more horrible.
Thank you for this touching and yes, eloquent and profound, post.
November 15, 2007 at 4:14 am
pricklypearbloom
Thank you, Kirsty, for sharing this. You are one awesome lady.
November 15, 2007 at 4:53 am
denise
Yes, this was a very kind post. YOu are a very kind person. Thank you so much.
November 15, 2007 at 6:17 am
Erilyn
Love and Hugs - lots of them. Thank you Kirsty for so much.
November 15, 2007 at 10:19 am
erin
kirsty - thanks for sharing your story. i really liked reading about james. he sounds like a great kid.
November 15, 2007 at 3:22 pm
h&b
xx
I’m glad you introduced James to all of us ‘new friends’, so that he may be present, and known.
Now I will go and wash my face …
November 15, 2007 at 4:44 pm
soozadoo
Your club, it just sucks, it does, but you don’t need to me to tell you that.
This post is one of the many reasons that I rooooly like you, an articulate honesty of the good, the bad and the ugly.
November 15, 2007 at 8:00 pm
Leanne
Thanks for sharing - I’m not sure I would be strong enough to survive the death of one of my children - I loved reading about James he sounded like a great guy
November 15, 2007 at 11:13 pm
Tanya
Thankyou so much. This post has touched me more than I can say… just yet.
November 16, 2007 at 7:18 am
jude
i cannot imagine, but you have filled a hole with some amazing warmth and i admire your strength. wow.
November 16, 2007 at 10:52 am
Caitlin O'Connor
{hugs} and thanks you for very moving post.
I like the ancient Egyptian idea - that as long as the person’s name is spoken, they are still with us. (my simplified version, anyway.) I haven’t lost a child (only potential children…
but I miss my sister every day. I don’t want to ever stop missing her. But now I don’t’ miss her with sadness so much as joy for her life.
November 16, 2007 at 5:10 pm
Alice C
Tracey Petersen recommended your blog to me. I can only say that I know exactly what you are talking about and I am grateful that you are able to articulate it better than I could.
Thank you.
November 17, 2007 at 1:50 am
Lauri
Oh Kirsty-I didn’t know. But what a lovely boy! And I know all I can do is offer my very most sincerest sympathies and condolences…and I really do!
But what you said here, I can really identify with: “There’s a pain in every new thing you do that doesn’t include your child. Going new places where they are not known hurts. Every new friend who never knew them is a reminder that your child is no longer physically present. You carry them with you, invisibly, and it feels as if the rest of the world is ignoring your precious child, not even acknowledging that they exist.”
I did not lose a child, but, I did lose my very dearest, best friend, companion, partner, EVER this past July. I think losing her is even harder than it would be losing my husband. The worst part about it is, she wasn’t my mom or sister or any kind of relative, she was “just” my friend. But no one understands what kind of friend she was and how important she was, and it does feel like it’s being ignored. Anyway, my point was that there really IS a pain in every new thing! Even a new restaurant. And in every old thing too…going somewhere WE used to go to together. Before she died (very suddenly) Steven and I had decided to adopt another baby. We were going to adopt from China, and were in the process of getting all the paperwork and red tape worked out. Then Gayla died. And I couldn’t possibly have a baby, something that would be such a HUGE part of my life, without Gayla knowing her. I just can’t do it now.
Sorry to leave such a novel length comment! James must have been hilarious! And yes, those words that become part of your family’s language…they are wonderful to have, aren’t they? And I’m glad you posted about this-most people don’t post about the bad things that happen, even though they are huge. You did a lovely job. Here’s to James!!!
November 19, 2007 at 7:25 pm
Dragonfly
Hi. I found you on one of my many blog trails from Alice’s blog. I am in your Club and your post is just how I feel too. I’m now off to read it from beginning to end and enjoy James through it…
November 20, 2007 at 10:42 am
Sue
Wow kirsty you wrote your feelings so well. Some people just don’t think and some people obviously don’t have feelings. It was really interesting reading your thoughts on everyone one that passes through your life makes it what it is now.
November 21, 2007 at 7:56 am
Helen
Kirsten,
Thank you for sharing this. I have never had children so I know there is no way I can ever get close to really identifying with your experience. But I feel all the richer for having been introduced to James and actually thoroughly ashamed that one ( just one of the many many reasons I chose not to have children) was the ‘risk’ of a child with a disabilty. Tonight I reaslise that avoiding that possible ‘risk’ means a certainty that I will never have the love and blessing your son gave you. Its still the right decision for me for all the other reasons but you made me see things differently.
Helen.
November 22, 2007 at 8:01 am
Aunty Evil
This is my first time visiting you. Your post about James touched my heart. I don’t know what it is like to lose a much loved one, but I know the day will come.
You have written this post in such a way that even if I have not experienced the pain in the way you have, I can relate to it.
I wish you and your family happiness. You were lucky to have James in your life, and he was lucky to have you.
November 27, 2007 at 4:15 am
Monica
you’re a strong woman and an inspiration to all of us!
November 27, 2007 at 3:46 pm
suzi-k
wow Kirsty, this is a beautiful and profound expression of how you feel, and thanks for the link, I enjoyed meeting James. The joyful, fun-loving side of him BEAMS out of that photo, testament that he was so loved and secure.
The thing I have always admired about you, and it positively leaps out of this post, is your ability to accept people, and life, warts and all. To celebrate the good stuff but at the same time, not gloss over the negative side, so that an honest, balanced perspective is always the result.
In the July 06 post, you said “Grandma will by now be upset that I’m only telling you negative things”, which of course was not true because you also said lots of positive stuff, but that generation did tend to believe that one didn’t speak of the bad stuff. And I personally believe it was what resulted in so many ‘family secrets’, like not telling kids they were adopted, or pretending granny was mommy to hide the fact that sister is actually mommy. So much unneccessary pain has been caused by these “secrets”. And you probably know by now that family secrets is one of my hobby horses, I did a huge rant about it recently! So your tell it like it is approach is really cool, and one of the reasons I so enjoy your blog, and feel like I have known you for years. From now on, whenever you take us anywhere in blogland words, we will picture James as part of it. Thanks for sharing.
November 30, 2007 at 5:26 am
sbwrites
My cousin died when she was 27 years old and in November she would have turned 50. I was suggesting to my aunt that she might be interested in creating a memorial blog for my cousin and was looking for links and found yours. What a wonderful idea to have a group for mothers whose children have died. On behalf of my aunt, thank you!
December 9, 2007 at 11:17 am
Betty
I lost my Son on Sept. 8, 2000….. My heart is still in a million pieces. I deal with it as I feel I should…. Some people think I am a Super Hero because I don’t cry alot.. Well not in front of them at least… I have also been told that I should be over it…. Never will that happen… Holidays are the hardest on me, but I get through them, not very easily I might add….But I do it. I just want to wish you all A VERY MERRY CHRISTMAS…And always remember…Your ANGELS are ALWAYS with you…..
From one VERY SAD SOUL to ANOTHER…… You are still loved, even though you may not be told alot anymore…..
Betty……. New Jersey
December 10, 2007 at 4:13 am
Jeri
Kirsty, I just stumbled across you today. I am also in the club. Your post - it says it all. Every thought I’ve ever had. We lost our 16 year old son almost 11 years ago. Not a day goes by… well, you know. The things we have missed - big things and little things - our younger son’s wedding this year, he should have been the best man. What would he be today? *sigh* I know I’ve tortured my dear friends at times because I must say his name, talk about the memories, keep him alive within me. And yeah, everyone thinks we are “so strong”.
Hugs,
Jeri
December 19, 2007 at 11:43 am
the Mater
I’ve been away much too long but you have not lost your touch. What a gift - to be so honest, so open, so real. Thank you for doing what you do so well - being yourself. I hope to return soon and catch up.
I remember our prior conversations about your beautiful son. You bring him to life when you share your memories.
Peace, E
January 1, 2008 at 12:24 pm
Sheye
My friend Susannah (Soozadoo) sent me your link today after I posted about the dread of New Years Eve, being a member of The Club. You write beautifully, words and thoughts so very familiar to me and all other members, I have no doubt.
Thankyou, I can’t wait to read all about your beautiful boy.
Sheye Rosemeyer
loving Mummy to Ava.
May 10, 2008 at 1:12 am
Valoree
Does anyone know where I would find a poem or e-card for my best friend who lost her only child when he was eighteen it has been 6 years and I would like to get her something this Mother’s Day special.
May 12, 2008 at 11:17 pm
makingyourdashcount
I just found your blog.. I too am a member of this club. Stinks, doesn’t it? Today would be my 16 year old daughter’s 20th birthday. I get through this date every year celebrating that this is the day that made me a mom! I LOVE being a mom!
Valoree, the lyrics to Stephen Schwartz’ song “For Good” from Wicked, is a beautiful sentiment.